Elijah Interfaith Institute Condemns Rabbi Yitzhak Shapira’s book

Rabbi Dr. Alon Goshen-Gottstein runs an interfaith Institute in Jerusalem, which mainly holds international conferences of the world’s religious leaders, bringing together world leaders who generally do not get a chance to meet. He successfully brings important teachers of the dharma together to meet western religious leaders. He also holds a variety of academic meetings.

Alon Goshen-Gottstein’s institute issued a public statement last week against Jewish views that rob non-Jews of their dignity and right to life inherent in their Image of God. It was precipitated by the controversy around Rabbi Yitzhak Shapira’s book which suggested the killing of children. For a summary of the rabbis who supported Shapira – see here in Hebrew. Here is the petition to the Israeli Supreme court asking the court to censure Yitzhak Shapira. There were good op-eds in YNET that, as far as I know, did not get translated for the English edition. I was waiting for the translations. One is by Rav Yoel Bin-Nun on how this new trend in the Religious Zionist world is against the approach of Rav Kook, and Rav Kook did not think the laws of war apply today. The other was by Rav Benny Lau who castigates the rabbis supporting the work, how Rav Amital taught him that this racism is the wrong approach, and that one cannot claim academic freedom for a beit midrash.
For some of the historical background of these changes from an outsider perspective, see Firestone, Reuven, “Holy War in Modern Judaism? “Mitzvah War” and the Problem of the “Three Vows” Journal of the American Academy of Religion – Volume 74, Number 4, December 2006, pp. 954-982

Now, Alon Goshen-Gottstein has moved his educational institute into a public role and condemned the racism and hatred of gentiles.

Affirming the Image of God:
Statement of Scholars of the Jewish Theology Project of the Elijah Interfaith Institute

Recent weeks and months have brought to public attention the issue of Jewish attitudes to non-Jews, as these are found in some traditional sources and halakhah (Jewish religious law), particularly with reference to Rabbi Yitzchak Shapira’s book Torat Hamelekh. The great liberty with which the author dispenses with the life of non-Jews under various circumstances has become a scandal in the media, a subject for police investigation for incitement, a discussion item on antisemitic websites, and the subject of an appeal to the Supreme Court of Israel. It has engendered heated discussion, most of which has focused on the right to teach Torah and to engage in discussion of halakhah, especially of a theoretical nature, unencumbered by external considerations and factors, such as police and state control. While these issues may be legitimate subjects for discussion, they conceal the main concerns raised by these teachings and their public reception. Many Rabbinical authorities have subsequently failed to condemn these teachings in theoretical and practical terms, leaving the impression that these are indeed appropriate contemporary Jewish attitudes to non-Jews.

For this reason, we, rabbis, teachers and scholars of Jewish studies of various disciplines, religious denominations and political perspectives, from different countries worldwide, have come together to express with a united voice our deep disdain for these extremist teachings, which are opposed to fundamental Jewish conceptions of the unity of humanity which all Jews affirm at this time of year on the High Holidays. We assert that the core issue they raise must be given priority in Jewish education and thought. Our view is that Jewish teaching involves more than merely citing texts, whether in or out of context. Teaching and the art of halakhic ruling always reflect a broader religious worldview, guided by core values. In our understanding, the creation of humanity in God’s image is the great principle, as our sages recognized.[1] We believe this mandates full respect for the infinite value, equality and uniqueness of every human life, for it is created in the image of God. Our Torah’s ways are ways of pleasantness and all her paths are peace.[2] These and other great principles are the guidelines through which we interpret and teach our tradition.[3]

We are working together under the aegis of the Elijah Interfaith Institute, to bring to light teachings of Judaism that cohere to this worldview. Love of one’s own group should not be equated with the hatred of others. Israel’s calling is harmonious with the wellbeing of all humanity. We recognize that there are voices in our tradition that have lost sight of thise great principles, because of the unspeakable suffering that our people have undergone throughout history. It is, therefore, a contemporary educational and halakhic challenge to confront these extremist teachings, to contain them, and to dissent from them publicly, applying the methods of halakhah, classical interpretation and historical study.

We have been collaborating on a project of developing a contemporary Jewish approach to other religions, that would make our students and communities aware of the dangers inherent in such extremist views in our tradition, and that would inspire a broader view of Judaism, its ethical task and its vision for humanity.

Accordingly, we call upon rabbis and educators to take a clear stand against narrow views Jewish particularity, in favor of a broader vision of Judaism’s relations to the other. Our scholars stand ready to debate the views under discussion. Our own critique of Torat Hamelekh will shortly be published on this website. We will also be publishing educational resources that provide an alternative view of the non-Jew in Judaism, that remind us that “The Lord is good to all, and His compassion extends to all His creatures.”[4]
[1]See Sifra Qedoshim 4; Mishnah Avot 3:14.
[2]Proverbs 3:17.
[3] We are painfully aware that such problematic theoretical teachings can easily become transformed into practical guidelines for action, as witnessed by horrifying acts such as the Hebron massacre by Goldstein in 1994. We also recall some tragic lessons of our history, and the actions of Israel’s enemies in the past century, applying a perverted logic that we should not replicate within Jewish teaching. For example, the right to kill children lest they grow up to threaten us was cited by Otto Ohlendorf of the German Army Einsatzgruppe C at his trial, to justify his unit’s shooting of tens or hundreds of thousands of Jewish children among the more than million Jews murdered by the shooting squads in Eastern Europe in 1941-1942.
[4] Psalm 145:9.

4 responses to “Elijah Interfaith Institute Condemns Rabbi Yitzhak Shapira’s book

  1. As you probably recall, last summer at the World Congress at the session on anti-gentile sources a certain scholar said that he would not publish anything relating to certain highly problematic views of a certain semi-prominent hareidi rabbi. The upshot is that most people outside of the very small subset of people who read this rabbis published work remain unaware of what he has written.

    What would the harm have been in ignoring Torat Hamelech instead of making it into a cause celebre?

    • Once the petition was filed to the high court, they took it seriously, and then the protagonists created some public high drama in Israel. As you notice, no one is mentioning the American haredi rabbi. And that same scholar signed onto this document.

  2. The petition did not just ask the Court to censure Rabbi Shapira, but requested that all copies of Torat ha-Meloekh be impounded and that criminal charges be brought against him. While I fully share the sentiments expressed in the petiton, I do not believe that attempting to initiate legal proceedings was the best way ot go.

  3. Muslims in the U.S. and worldwide are routinely faulted for failing to condemn their terrorist. Jews–at minimum–have no moral ground from which to fault our Muslim neighbors if we won’t stand up and reject Yitzhak Shapira and his terrorist enterprise. Talmidei chachamim m’arbim shalom b’olam. If they’re inciting violence in the world, they are not wise students (of halakhah).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s